Five for Five

Created on 2/20/2007, last active awhile ago.

"Lists of five films with one common element, but a different rating"

Join this group

Interested in: No particular genre

Description: This group is all about making lists of five films each. The films in each list share a common element (lead actor, director, etc...). Each film must have a different star rating from you. So one film has one star, another one has two, another three, and so on up to five. So there you go, who has made classics, crap, and everything in between?

[more]

Doesn't work for me

Note: you must join this group to add to this discussion.

Sort discussion:

Risselada Posts 2068	2/20/2007 5:42 PM posted awhile ago Doesn't work for me Wow, I'll take a stab at this game. But I've only rated 17 movies with one star. That's not a lot to choose from. If any of you have seen much more, why are you watching so many crappy movies!? Maybe I'm more gracious with my ratings. I'm not sure.

porcupine Posts 97	2/20/2007 9:08 PM posted awhile ago Re: Doesn't work for me I ran into the same problem. The truth is that I haven't actually seen (or seen all of) some of my one and two star movies. Sometimes seeing just a scene (or trailer) and an overwhelming critical consensus that a movie is crap is more than enough to give it one star.

Risselada Posts 2068	2/21/2007 12:17 AM posted awhile ago Re: Doesn't work for me Fair enough. I'll see if I can have some fun with it.

Risselada Posts 2068	2/21/2007 12:28 AM posted awhile ago Re: Doesn't work for me Uh maybe I don't know how to use this thing. Or maybe you have to be a group leader. But I can't figure out how to make any new group lists. Got any help for me?

porcupine Posts 97	2/21/2007 2:51 PM posted awhile ago Re: Doesn't work for me I've promoted you to a group leader, so i think you should now be able to create lists. sorry about that. that kind of sucks that members can't make lists. maybe i'll have to talk to someone about that...

Puhnner Posts 239	2/21/2007 5:38 PM posted awhile ago 1 through 5 Ok, I need to admit that my ratings are all but consistent, but here is an attempt: Nicholas Cage Raising Arizona 5 or Leaving Las Vegas 5 Lord of War 4 Face/Off 3 ( although I have it as 4 ) 8MM 2 Windtalkers 1 or the Rock 1 Funny, the Bruce Willis list, I have 3 of the 5 as 5's and the other 2, though unseen I suspect I would place a solid 1 by each; merely my opinion. I have to relook at Oliver Stone from this lens, he would probably work fine too.

Risselada Posts 2068	2/22/2007 10:52 AM posted awhile ago Re: Doesn't work for me porcupine: I've promoted you to a group leader, so i think you should now be able to create lists. sorry about that. that kind of sucks that members can't make lists. maybe i'll have to talk to someone about that... Cool thanks for making me a leader. I guess it depends on the situation whether or not any member should be able to make a list. It seems like the group leader should be able to decide if other regular members can make a list or not.