Movie news on your iPhone today!
Advertisement
Sign in
Username   Password         Forgot password?
Wanna join? Sign up
Find movies you'll love
"Play games. Win prizes."


Group Owners (2)

Advertisement
Recasting GHOSTBUSTERS (1984)
Note: you must join this group to add to this discussion.
Sort discussion:

achance42
achance42
Posts 17

Re:Recasting GHOSTBUSTERS (1984)



Alfred Hitchcock's The Ghost Busters (1955)

Dr. Peter Venkman - Cary Grant

Dr. Ray Stantz - Jimmy Stewart

Dr. Egon Spengler - Gregory Peck

Winston Zeddemore - Farley Granger (not a lot of black actors in Hitchcock films, so he'd probably cast someone younger instead)

Dana Barrett - Grace Kelly

Janine Melnitz - Shirley MacLaine

Louis Tully - Hume Cronyn

Walter Peck - Norman Lloyd

Mayor - Ray Milland

Gozer - Kim Novak, in her breakout role (voiced by James Mason)



     
Under discussion:

Ghostbusters  (1984)

            
indieabby88
indieabby88
Posts 327

Re:Recasting GHOSTBUSTERS (1984)



Jcarlon:

Ingmar Bergman’s Ghostbusters

Gunnar Björnstrand ... Dr. Peter Venkman

Åke Fridell ... Dr. Raymond Stantz

Max Von Sydow ... Dr. Egon Spengler

Erland Josephson ... Winston Zeddmore

Ingrid Bergman ... Dana Barrett

Nils Poppe ... Louis Tully

Liv Ullmann ... Janine Melnitz

Bengt Ekeroth ... Walter Peck

Folke Sundquist ... Male Student

Jullan Kindahl ... Female Student

Bibi Andersson ... Gozer

Victor Sjöström ... The Librarian

A spider in a wine glass … Slimer

A cracked mirror in a finely-wrapped box … Stay Puft Marshmallow Man

In Bergman’s Ghostbusters, the plot is the same, except that when the team is confronted with Slimer during the hotel sequence, the Ghostbusters become existentially horrified by his existence and give up ghostbusting in a deep spiritual confusion. Ray and Winston turn to alcoholism and the church. Venkman and Dana’s love affair is abandoned when she is driven mad by the haunting and is committed to an insane asylum. The rest of the film follows Egon and Janine’s unrequited romance, culminating in her climbing to the roof of the Ghostbuster headquarters to commit suicide. There she meets a sobbing Venkman, where, wordlessly, they join hands and hurl themselves to their deaths. The climax is an extended conversation between Louis Tully and Walter Peck on the human need to explain the unknown through superstition. Here we learn Gozer was Tully’s childhood sweetheart who died of lead poisoning while working a summer job at a locksmith’s. The film ends with the two men opening the door to the containment chamber, which is revealed to lead to the bedroom of Dana Barret’s apartment. They spend the silent final scene of the film trying to reassemble the broken eggs on her kitchen counter. Also, there are no jokes and all the ghosts are metaphors.

Oh. My. God. This is freaking brilliant! I laughed myself silly.

     

            
DentedOneFilms
DentedOneFilms
Posts 1

Re:Recasting GHOSTBUSTERS (1984)



 

Dennis Leary    ...     Dr. Peter Venkman

John Cusack    ...     Dr. Raymond Stantz

Steve Buscemi    ...     Dr. Egon Spengler

Ving Rhames    ...     Winston Zeddmore

Cate Blachette    ...     Dana Barrett

Tony Hale    ...     Louis Tully

Siobhan Fallon    ...     Janine Melnitz

Will Arnett    ...     Walter Peck

Rip Torn    ...     Mayor

Jay Baruchel    ...     Male Student

Katrina Bowden    ...     Female Student

Tilda Swinton    ...     Gozer

Mercedes McCambridge     ...     Gozer (voice)

Tone Loc     ...     Zuul

Flea          Slimer (voice)

Marcia Gay Harden          The Librarian

John Goodman          Stay-Puft Marshmallow Man



     

            
vh8686
vh8686
Posts 1

Re:Recasting GHOSTBUSTERS (1984)



Alright here goes.... Mel Brooks' Ghostbusters

Gene Wilder*         ...    Peter Venkman

Gene Wilder*         ...   Egon Spengler

Dom Deluise        ...   Raymond Stantz

Cleavon Little or

Gregory Hines     ...   Winston Zeddmore

Julianne Moore   ...   Dana Barrett

Marty Feldman    ...   Louis Tully

Madeline kahn    ...  Janine Melnitz

Richard Lewis    ...  Walter Peck

Mel Brooks          ...  Mayor Lenny

Cloris Leachman .. Gozer

Lee Meredith        ... Female Student

Stephen Weber ... Male Student

Orson Welles    ... Slimer

* I could see Gene Wilder play either one really so possible alternates that I would think of would be Bruce Campbell for Venkman and John Turturro for Egon.



     

            
Risselada
Risselada
Posts 2068

Re:Recasting GHOSTBUSTERS (1984)



achance42:
Winston Zeddemore - Farley Granger (not a lot of black actors in Hitchcock films, so he'd probably cast someone younger instead)

It's funny that so many people thing he has to be black.

Actually if it was a Hitchcock movie, do you think it would have had any black people?



     

            
SkyPilot
SkyPilot
Posts 576

Re:Recasting GHOSTBUSTERS (1984)



Wow, it was hard to pick a winner, but it’s frozenhamster for his 4/20 post--

“Ghostbusters: London Calling. An Edgar Wright Film

…England is about to get slimed! When ghosts get a passport to Europe they take London by storm and it's up to a special team of British parapsychologists to save the city. Killing ghosts and making jokes, all before tea time.”

Steve Coogan (24 Hour Party People) as Peter Venkman, Simon Pegg (Hot Fuzz) as Ray, Martin Freeman (Tim on the British Office) and Nick Frost (Hot Fuzz) as Winston. Besides being a really fun idea, I like it because it’s its own thing and doesn’t try to “replace” anyone, especially the inimitable Bill Murray.

Second prize: minerwerks – your post is a tour de force of film history, and thank you for directing our thoughts to the demented world of David Heavener (Kill Crazy).

I'd also like to mention lazyalchemist's post. I especially liked imagining Rainn Wilson (The Office’s Dwight) as Egon, Michael Cera (Juno) as the male student, and Alan Rickman (Sheriff of Nottingham!) provide the voice of Gozer. I can see Vince Vaughn doing a pretty good Peter Venkman, too. You’ll notice that Vince was the popular favorite for Venkman.

I’ve got to salute some others:

smcassidy also went with Vince Vaughn for Peter, but he followed that with two perfect sucker punches:  Jerry O’Connell (Joe’s Apartment) for Ray, and David Duchovny (X-Files) as Egon.
Luis Guzman (Punch-Drunk Love) would make a great Winston (thanks LMCBoy).
Keira Knightley is a surreal and inspired choice for Gozer (thanks PlantPage55).

And mercurial, I may have less faith than you do in the Broken Lizard (Super Troopers) comedy team, but these are good picks.



     
Under discussion:

Kill Crazy  (1989)

Joe's Apartment  (1996)

Super Troopers  (2002)

Punch-Drunk Love  (2002)

Hot Fuzz  (2007)

Juno  (2007)

            
minerwerks
minerwerks
Posts 21

Re:Recasting GHOSTBUSTERS (1984)



SkyPilot:
Second prize: minerwerks – your post is a tour de force of film history, and thank you for directing our thoughts to the demented world of David Heavener (Kill Crazy).

Wow, I am amazed! Thanks so much, and nothing can describe the surprise and joy I experienced hearing Adam and Matty reviewing my Woody Allen Ghostbusters cast on Filmspotting!



     
Under discussion:

Kill Crazy  (1989)

            
adamkemp
adamkemp
Posts 54

Re:Recasting GHOSTBUSTERS (1984)



minerwerks:

SkyPilot:
Second prize: minerwerks – your post is a tour de force of film history, and thank you for directing our thoughts to the demented world of David Heavener (Kill Crazy).

Wow, I am amazed! Thanks so much, and nothing can describe the surprise and joy I experienced hearing Adam and Matty reviewing my Woody Allen Ghostbusters cast on Filmspotting!

minerwerks, please email feedback@filmspotting.net with your name and address and we will get your prize out to you. Thanks!



     
Under discussion:

Kill Crazy  (1989)

            
chassiah
chassiah
Posts 3

Re:Recasting GHOSTBUSTERS (1984)



did this end yet... anyway

BRITISH COMEDY CLASS OF 2000 CAST

dir: Edgar Wright, written by: Simon Pegg & Nick Frost

simon pegg    ...     Dr. Peter Venkman

 

nick frost    ...     Dr. Raymond Stantz

 

stephen magnan    ...     Dr. Egon Spengler

 

paterson joseph    ...     Winston Zeddmore 

 

noel fielding (in drag)   ...     Dana Barrett  

 

richard ayoade    ...     Louis Tully

 

meredith macneill    ...     Janine Melnitz

 

robert webb    ...     Walter Peck

 

ricky gervais    ...     Mayor

mark heap    ...     Male Student

kate ashfield    ...     Female Student

mackenzie crook    ...     Gozer 

matt berry     ...     Gozer (voice) (uncredited)



     

            
chassiah
chassiah
Posts 3

Re:Recasting GHOSTBUSTERS (1984)



damn.

i'm late to the plate

my browser wouldn't load the other entries when i was entering my suggestions.

now viewing on firefox & realized the person who won had a similar list.

F me.

can't wait for the next recast.



     

            
<< Previous 1 ... 4 5 6 7 8 9 Next >> 71-80 of 81
 
RSS