Frem Here To Awesome Festival
Advertisement

"Recast movies that will never be remade"

Interested in: No particular genre

Group Owners (2)

Advertisement

Re:Recasting THE BREAKFAST CLUB (1985) 
You must join this group to add to this discussion
SkyPilot
SkyPilot
Posts 168

Recasting THE BREAKFAST CLUB (1985)



 

Is there any potential for another Brat Pack, or could such a group only exist in the 80s? Maybe recasting The Breakfast Club will give us our answer.

    Emilio Estevez       ...       Andrew 'Andy' Clark

    Anthony Michael Hall    ...     Brian Ralph Johnson

    Judd Nelson    ...     John Bender

    Molly Ringwald    ...     Claire Standish

    Ally Sheedy    ...     Allison Reynolds
   
    Paul Gleason    ...     Principal Richard Vernon

    John Kapelos    ...     Carl the Janitor



     
Under discussion:

            
JCC1109
JCC1109
Posts 2

Recasting THE BREAKFAST CLUB (1985)...Del Boca Vista Active Senior Community Edition



Andrew "andy' Clark....robert redford

Brian Ralph Johnson....Woody Allen

John Bender....Jack Nicholson

Claire Standish....Shirley MacLaine

Allison Reynolds.....Dame Judi Dench

Outdoor Activities Coordinator Vernon.....Eugene Levy

Carl the Janitor....Sean Hayes (Will and Grace)



     

            
benthams_head
benthams_head
Posts 5

Re:Recasting THE BREAKFAST CLUB (1985)



Okay, my choice for Andy is pushing 30, which is old even by John Hughes standards (I calculate that one human year is approximately equivalent to 1.35 Hughes years), but I can’t imagine anyone but Ben McKenzie in that role. Also, I’ve avoided, and would challenge everyone else to avoid, inclusion of any “Juno” cast members (even though J.K. Simmons would make a great Principal Vernon). It’s sort of like The Strokes covering Velvet Underground’s “There She Goes Again”.  Finally, I always felt that the prettification of Ally Sheedy was one of the original film’s serious missteps. Hopefully my choice of Allisons renders that somewhat implausible.

 

Without further ado, I give you The Breakfast Club: ’08 Style….

 

Ben McKenzie       ...       Andrew 'Andy' Clark

   Jesse Eisenberg    ...     Brian Ralph Johnson

   Taylor Kitsch      ...     John Bender

    Anna Kendrick    ...     Claire Standish

    Heather Matarazzo    ...     Allison Reynolds
   
    Dylan Baker    ...     Principal Richard Vernon

    Jim Jarmusch    ...     Carl the Janitor

 

One other note to whomever greenlights this production: please, please, PLEASE do not let Fall Out Boy cover “Don’t You (Forget About Me)”.



     

            
kevdo
kevdo
Posts 1

Re:Recasting THE BREAKFAST CLUB (1985)



Tried to go serious with the recasting, trying to get actors who could fill the essence of their Brat Pack counterparts.

 

    James Van Der Beek       ...       Andrew 'Andy' Clark  

    Jay Baruchel    ...     Brian Ralph Johnson

    Ethan Hawke    ...     John Bender

    Winona Ryder    ...     Claire Standish

    Jodie Foster circa 1975  ...     Allison Reynolds

    J.K. Simmons    ...     Principal Richard Vernon

    Will Ferrell or Ben Stiller (take your pick) ...     Carl the Janitor



     

            
mercurial
mercurial
Posts 109

Re:Recasting THE BREAKFAST CLUB (1985)



The Breakfast Club

Brady Corbet      -      Andrew Clark (The Athlete)

Jay Baruchel      -      Brian Ralph Johnson (The Brain)

Mark Webber      -      John Bender (The Criminal)

Blake Lively       -      Claire Standish (The Princess)

Nora Zehetner    -      Allison Reynolds (The Basket Case)

Paul Giamatti      -      Richard Vernon (The Principal)

Scott Bakula      -      Carl (The Janitor)

 

Brady Corbet (Funny Games) fits perfectly in the All-American Jock stereotype. Jay Baruchel (Almost Famous) plays the geek better than most. Mark Webber (Stroytelling) is a genuinely disaffected youth. Blake Lively (The Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants) looks like a prom queen. Nora Zehetner (Brick) could definitely pull off the fragile, awkward loner. Paul Giamatti (Sideways) will bring a touch of class to the production as the irksome school principal. Scott Bakula (American Beauty) has that wisdom-spouting man with a mop quality that would be perfect for the janitor.

 



     
Under discussion:

American Beauty  (1999)

Almost Famous  (2000)

Storytelling  (2001)

Sideways  (2004)

Brick  (2005)

Funny Games  (2007)

            
leeroy711
leeroy711
Posts 86

Re:Recasting THE BREAKFAST CLUB (1985)



 

The Breakfast Club

 Chad Micheal Murray (One Tree Hill)     -      Andrew Clark (The Athlete)

Micheal Cera (Juno, Superbad)      -      Brian Ralph Johnson (The Brain)

Justin Timberlake (Southland Tales)      -      John Bender (The Criminal)

 Lacey Chabert (Mean Girls)      -      Claire Standish (The Princess)

Ellen Page (Juno)    -      Allison Reynolds (The Basket Case)

 Mathew Fox (Lost)     -      Richard Vernon (The Principal)

Andre 3000  (Outkast)    -      Carl (The Janitor)



     
Under discussion:

Mean Girls  (2004)

Southland Tales  (2006)

Superbad  (2007)

Juno  (2007)

            
indieabby88
indieabby88
Posts 230

Re:Recasting THE BREAKFAST CLUB (1985)



Alright, let's take a stab at this thing, shall we?

Channing Tatum (Stop-Loss) - Andrew Clark

Lou Taylor Pucci (Thumbsucker) - Brian Ralph Johnson

Charlie Hunnam (Green Street Hooligans)- John Bender

Kate Bosworth (21) -Claire Standish

Nora Zehetner (Brick) -Allison Reynolds

Vincent D'Onofrio -Richard Vernon

Anthony Michael Hall- Carl

 



     
Under discussion:

Thumbsucker  (2005)

Brick  (2005)

Stop-Loss  (2007)

21  (2008)

            
Cammmalot
Cammmalot
Posts 4

Re:Recasting THE BREAKFAST CLUB (1985)



   

                                            Of The Breakfast Club!

 

In which Bryan Singer decides to give in to his urge to reunite with his most successful ensemble. In a nearly fruitless search for the perfect script he stumbles upon a rewrite of the Breakfast Club.  In this revision story elements are basically the same, however, the setting is changed from 9 hours in a detention hall to overnight in a Detainment center. 

 

Stephen Baldwin      -      Andrew Clark (The Athlete)

Kevin Pollak      -      Brian Ralph Johnson (The Brain)

Gabriel Byrne      -      John Bender (The Criminal)

Kevin Spacey       -      Claire Standish (The Princess)

Benicio Del Toro    -      Allison Reynolds (The Basket Case)

Chazz Palminteri      -      Richard Vernon (The Principal)

Pete Postlewaite      -      Carl (The Janitor)

 

 <a href="http://www.flickr.com/photos/26280691@N07/2466060392/" title="theusual-breakfast_club by cammmalot, on Flickr"><img src="http://farm3.static.flickr.com/2018/2466060392_da4166cce2.jpg" width="327" height="500" alt="theusual-breakfast_club" /></a>



     

            
moleman
moleman
Posts 1

Re:Recasting THE BREAKFAST CLUB (1985)



The Breakfast Club - A Judd Apatow Musical remake of the 80's classic...

 

    Bradley Cooper  ...  Andrew 'Andy' Clark

   Michael Cera    ...     Brian Ralph Johnson

    Jack White    ...     John Bender

    Amy Adams    ...     Claire Standish

    Zooey Deschanel    ...     Allison Reynolds
    
    Jeremy Piven    ...     Principal Richard Vernon

    David Duchovny    ...     Carl the Janitor



     

            
SPL3000
SPL3000
Posts 2

Re:Recasting THE BREAKFAST CLUB (1985)



Here is my list (assume all ages being equal at 17-18 years old).

Andy Clark (The Jock) - Jason Scwartzman

Brian Ralph Johnson (The brain) - James McEvoy

John Bender (The rebel) -  Casey Affleck

Claire (The princess) - Katherine Heigl

Allison (The darky or ugly-beautifull girl)- Zooey Deschanel

Principal Richard Vernon - Steve Buscemi

Carl the janitor - Jason Lee.



     

            
1 2 3 4 5 6 Next >> 1-10 of 54
 
RSS