This first of three film adaptations of Dashiel Hammett's The Maltese Falcon plays at times like the road-company version of the more famous 1941
John Huston/
Humphrey Bogart adaptation.
Ricardo Cortez stars as a slick, rogueish edition of Sam Spade, using his office as a trysting place for his various
amours.
Bebe Daniels plays the Brigid O'Shaughnessy character, here rechristened Ruth Wonderly. Ruth hires Spade and his partner Miles Archer (
Walter Long) to locate her missing sister. Archer is killed while on duty, confirming Spade's suspicion that Ruth's lost-sister story was a subterfuge. In fact, Ruth is one of several disreputable types in search of a valuable falcon statuette encrusted with jewels. Others mixed up in the quest for the "black bird" are portly Casper Gutman (
Dudley Digges), Gutman's neurotic gunsel Wilmer (
Dwight Frye, better known as Renfield from
Dracula) and effeminate Joel Cairo (
Otto Matiesen). It is giving nothing away at this stage of the game to note that, after all the various intrigues concerning the falcon have come and gone, Spade turns Ruth over to the cops as the murderer of Archer. As would be the case with the 1941 version, the 1931
Maltese Falcon does not use Hammett's original ending, in which Spade callously resumes his affair with Archer's widow (
Thelma Todd). Instead, we are offered a jailhouse coda, where a suddenly compassionate Spade asks the matron to treat the incarcerated Ruth gently during her 20-year stay. When
Maltese Falcon was due for a reissue in 1936, it was denied a Production Code approval on the basis of one single line: Archer's widow, spotting Ruth Wonderly in Spade's bedroom, exclaims "Who's that dame in my kimono?" In between the 1931 and 1941 versions of
Maltese Falcon, there would be a heavily disguised reworking of the Hammett novel,
Satan Met a Lady (1936), starring
Warren William and
Bette Davis. To avoid confusion with the 1941 remake, the 1931
Maltese Falcon has been retitled Dangerous Female for television. ~ Hal Erickson, All Movie Guide