Madagascar: Escape 2 Africa (2008)

Reuniting the all-star comedy lineup from the first film, Madagscar: Escape 2 Africa picks up right where that one left off, with best friends Alex the Lion (Ben Stiller), Marty the Zebra (Chris Rock), Melman the Giraffe (David Schwimmer), and Gloria the Hippo (Jada Pinkett Smith) plotting their return to the Central Park Zoo after being stranded in the titular island nation. After a disastrous plane ride -- courtesy of some militarily inclined penguins -- they instead end up at an African wildlife reserve, where Alex has an unexpected reunion with the parents he was separated from as a cub. This storyline, in which Alex attempts to win the acceptance of his alpha-lion Dad, is so tired that not even a go-for-broke Alec Baldwin, as the scheming bad guy, can salvage it. Baldwin isn't the only one giving it his all, because Sacha Baron Cohen, who provided the funniest moments in the first film as King Julien the Lemur, returns with a mad gusto that makes the film worthwhile whenever his character is onscreen. Like Robin Williams in Aladdin, Cohen flowers here because of the visual freedoms that animation allows. The filmmakers make sure Julien's physical look matches the voice no matter how demented it gets, and they succeed so grandly that you feel an anticipatory buzz during all his scenes because truly anything could happen. If both Madagascar films were just about Julien and the penguin commando squad they would be comic gems. Unfortunately, for all the stuff that works well in Madagascar 2, the movie suffers from a serious case of unoriginality, largely because DreamWorks slavishly adheres to the recipe they believe made Shrek a box-office giant: genuine wit + fart jokes + gooey sentiment + overly familiar pop tunes = cross-generational appeal. This time around, the incessant onslaught of music and gags never gels with the overly familiar storylines -- resulting in a film that barely satisfies an entire family. The Madagascar movies are like family meal deals from a chain restaurant that only serves pizzas loaded with everything -- it might seem like a good idea while you're all eating, but after the meal you understand that nobody got what they really wanted. ~ Perry Seibert, All Movie Guide