Review by All Movie Guide
All Movie Guide
is neutral about it.
An immensely popular tearjerker, Love is a Many-Splendored Thing has dated very badly through the years, but it still holds great appeal for aficionados of good soap operas. As an over-the-top romantic melodrama, it's hard to beat, but those who are not prone to tearing up at the sight of a forlorn
Jennifer Jones standing bravely and lonely atop a high, windy hill would be well advised to look elsewhere -- and quickly.
Love makes no attempt to disguise its soapiness, and it wears its manipulative nature right out on its sleeve -- and that gets quite wearying after a while. Fortunately,
Love has a couple of classic weeper performances from Jones and
William Holden, both of whom knew just how to play this kind of material for maximum effectiveness. Even more fortunately,
Love has all the gorgeous surface trappings -- beautiful sets and scenery, gorgeous costumes, sumptuous photography, a sweepingly romantic score -- that provide the real joy in films of this type. The title song is also still memorable, although nowadays it may evoke laughter more than passion and tears.
Love is anything but a great film, but it's the kind of guilty pleasure that many find irresistible. ~ Craig Butler, All Movie Guide