H.M. Pulham, Esq. (1941)

A melancholy, adult drama about the fear of living one's life to its fullest, H.M. Pulham, Esq. has a simple message that still rings true for many people. Pulham demonstrates that there's nothing sadder than the missed opportunity, and that far too many people are willing to settle for what is safe and comfortable rather than take a risk that could result in failure. Yet, as Pulham demonstrates (until a somewhat inappropriate ending), settling for the safe and comfortable can be soul-deadening. It's a message that has been said before but that stands repeating, and Pulham makes its case in strong, dramatic terms (again, until the ending, which dampens the impact a bit). The screenplay is sensitive yet strong, and King Vidor's direction emphasizes its points without belaboring them. Robert Young is excellent in a difficult role which requires him to be passive and yet still propel the story forward. Ruth Hussey is equally fine as his wife, a perfectly suitable woman who just doesn't happen to be the woman he loves. There's also good work from Charles Coburn and Van Heflin, but the top acting honors go to Hedy Lamarr. Never considered a great actress, Lamarr here proves that, in the right role and with the right direction, she was capable of truly impressive work. She displays a warmth and feeling that is often missing from her other performances and makes one understand why Young would fall so deeply in love with her. It's a truly lovely performance in a film that is a richly rewarding little gem. ~ Craig Butler, All Movie Guide