Movie news on your iPhone today!
Advertisement
Sign in
Username   Password         Forgot password?
Wanna join? Sign up
Find movies you'll love
Band of Brothers: Why We Fight
  • 0
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • Rate this movie.

Rent it, watch it, find it

Advertisement
Directed by David Frankel
The men of Easy Company come face to face with the horrors of the Holocaust in "Why We Fight," the ninth installment of the HBO miniseries Band of Brothers. The episode opens with the company in Germany, where they find no enemy resistance. In fact, they find warm beds and hot meals in the houses they commandeer. Many of the men go about looting the German homes and farms for food and valuables. Spiers (Matthew Settle) is particularly industrious, sending several shipments home. At least one soldier is lucky enough to bed down with a willing fraulein. A new replacement, O'Keefe (Matt Hickey) arrives, and gets a typically cool reception from the veterans. Major Winters (Damian Lewis) is keeping a close eye on his friend, Nixon (Ron Livingston), who was recently involved in a jump in which nearly all the troops were killed. To make matters worse, Nixon gets the news that his wife is divorcing him. He starts devoting all of his energy to tracking down bottles of his favorite booze. It's clear to these men that the war is almost over, and they begin discussing their plans. Liebgott (Ross McCall) talks about going back to the cab company and finding "a nice Jewish girl," while Webster (Eion Bailey) plans to finish school at Harvard. The men have grown increasingly cynical about what they've accomplished in Europe. Then they make a gruesome discovery -- a small concentration camp in the woods of Landsberg. Several of these combat-hardened veterans break down when they see the condition of the prisoners. Winters and his men are shocked to learn that the men who have been starved and murdered at the camp are not criminals, but Jews, Poles, and Gypsies. ~ Josh Ralske, All Movie Guide
[More]
 
m_rturnagem_rturnage The Best Episode of the Series
by m_rturnage in m_rturnage Blog
loved it.
Was this review helpful? [Be the first to tell us!]
"In a series that puts an emphasis on action, this episode is like a splash of cold water in the face. In the middle of battle, a very fragile, very human face is brought to the forefront.This episode is artistic, beautiful, and horrifying all at once. " [More]
All Movie Guide Logo
Review by All Movie Guide
All Movie Guide
liked it.
In this emotionally shattering episode of HBO's acclaimed WWII miniseries Band of Brothers, the personal hardships and horror of war give way to a painfully clear understanding of the real evil the men of Easy Company have been fighting. At the beginning of "Why We Fight," written by John Orloff and directed by David Frankel, things have gotten a bit easier for Easy Company. The worst of the war is clearly over for most of them, and many are already thinking of returning home. But no one seems all that happy. Nixon (Ron Livingston) is distraught and drinking heavily after a planeload of paratroopers he was jumping with were senselessly killed. Perconte (James Madio) eloquently explains his frustration at being away from home for so long to a replacement, O'Keefe (Matt Hickey), who can't understand why the guys seem so hostile to him. It's an effective portrait of a bunch of cynical, hard-bitten men who are having a hard time adjusting to not being under fire. Their cynicism then dissolves in the face of the greatest horror of the war. Until they discovered the small concentration camp at Landsberg, these men were apparently unaware of the Nazis' efforts to eradicate the Jews. This is, by now, familiar subject matter, but by presenting the stunned reactions of these battle-weary characters -- characters we have grown to know -- this episode forces us to consider these circumstances afresh. (Eion Bailey), as the genial Webster, is again the audience's surrogate, portraying the young man's violent outburst in response to the German townspeople's claims of ignorance. Ross McCall is particularly touching portraying the Jewish Liebgott's shock, and his hopeless effort not to feel personally involved -- to continue doing his job in the face of an atrocity. ~ Josh Ralske, All Movie Guide
 

Community ratings

mavens
Spout mavens
haven't rated it
most people
Most people
liked it.

Other opinions

Jymkata
Jymkata
loved it.
m_rturnage
m_rturnage
loved it.
hthundar
hthundar
loved it.