Review by All Movie Guide
All Movie Guide
is neutral about it.
Takashi Miike's Audition begins as a rather light romantic drama about a middle-aged widower, Aoyama (
Ryo Ishibashi), a television producer, who decides to find a new wife by auditioning actresses for a film. Once Aoyama settles on Asami (model Eihi Shiina), the quietest, most demure-seeming woman, Miike slowly begins to reveal hints of the horror that is to come. Asami sits by the phone, presumably for days on end, in an apartment that's bare except for a large canvas bag. When Aoyama finally gives in to his desire, the phone rings, a cold smile slowly comes to Asami's lips, and, suddenly, the bag violently spasms, rocking across the floor. It's a masterful shot sequence that completely changes the tone and direction of the film. Miike's film works on the level of a pure horror film, but it also rewards viewers who are interested in its thematic concerns and filmmaking technique. The horrific final half-hour of the film is so effective because Miike has allowed the audience to spend time with Aoyama and understand the questionable behavior that leads him to his own personal hell, and because, as in
David Lynch's films, that hell is rendered in such a head-spinning, dreamlike way. If it were presented any more realistically, it would be unbearable to watch, and it would lose its effectiveness as metaphor. The film critiques the power imbalance that allows men to "audition" beautiful young women, looking for some fantasy combination of strength and servitude. Because Aoyama is, in the end, a sympathetic character, the sadistic revenge that Asami exacts can't be excused, but Aoyama's own creepy complicity must be acknowledged. The film is not for everyone, but for those who can stomach its gory denouement, it's a disturbing cinematic experience that they won't soon forget. ~ Josh Ralske, All Movie Guide