Auteur theorists who've charted the career of "cult" director Edgar G. Ulmer have seldom mentioned Carnegie Hall, simply because it was more expensive than most of Ulmer's films and thus can't be regarded a "low-budget masterpiece." The wafer-thin plotline concerns a young immigrant woman (
Marsha Hunt) who takes a job as a Carnegie Hall cleaning woman. Her love of music leads her to a better job in the Hall, and after several years she rises to the position of concert organizer. The woman uses her clout to promote her own son's career as a pianist. Carnegie Hall showcases a number of celebrated musicians. Selections include: Arthur Rubinstein performing Chopin's Polonaise in A Flat,
Jascha Heifetz performing Concerto for Violin and Orchestra in G Major by Tchaikovsky,
Ezio Pinza singing both the drinking song from Don Giovanni and one of the arias from Simon di Boccanegra,
Lily Pons singing The Bell Song from Lakme by Delibes, and
Jan Peerce singing O Sole Mio.The film also includes musical performances by Bruno Walter,
Rise Stevens, Gregor Piatagorsky,
Harry James,
Vaughn Monroe,
Leopold Stokowski, and others. ~ Hal Erickson, All Movie Guide