Review by All Movie Guide
All Movie Guide
is neutral about it.
Long ignored and forgotten, having fallen through the cracks of cinema history for over three decades, A Day With the Boys received renewed public and critical attention in mid-2002 when it made its home video debut, as a featurette on the Criterion Collection DVD of
David Gordon Green's superlative
George Washington (2000). A peerlessly frightening and disturbing mood piece by character actor turned one-time director
Clu Gulager,
A Day explores the manifestation of evil among pre-adolescents. Its thematic core and narrative trajectory (with a downward spiral into hell) mirror
Frank Perry's equally unsettling
Last Summer (1969). The coinciding of these two films in the same year can hardly be termed capricious, given the degree to which hate crime, violence, and bloodshed became commonplace around the end of the decade of hope. In that regard, Gulager's use of marching music on the wordless soundtrack hauntingly evokes U.S. military escalation in the late '60s and firmly establishes the film as a Vietnam allegory. The basic storyline suggests
The Twilight Zone or
Night Gallery (replete with a Serling-esque denouement), but no
Zone or
Gallery episode ever pushed so far, with a shocking conclusion guaranteed to make many viewers nauseous. The short would indeed be unbearable to watch if it did not rise above its depressing (and sociopathic) implications via Gulager and cinematographer
Laszlo Kovacs' sure-handed and fascinating presentation of the material. Psychedelically tinged, saturated with slow-motion sequences, solarization, freeze-frames, and visual balletics, the form of A Day with the Boys gains added creepiness via 35-year stylistic dating. Gulager's one effort behind the camera will devastate the queasy and the overly sensitive, and features an ending that challenges credibility ever so slightly (it needs minor adjustments to remain plausible), but once seen, A Day With the Boys burns an indelible impression into one's memory. ~ Nathan Southern, All Movie Guide