Music in My Heart (1940)

Plot didn't have to count for much in a musical film in 1940, as evidenced by Music in My Heart. Screenwriter James Edward Grant certainly doesn't seem to have taken it very seriously, never making any real attempt at bringing reality to the basic premise. This lack of credibility mitigates some of the fun of Music, as does the fact that the Robert Wright and George Forrest score is fairly hum-drum, with only "It's a Blue World" and to a lesser degree "Pulchinello" rising above average. Fortunately, director Joseph Santley treats the material as a lark, not worrying about its lack of reality, and concentrating instead on making sure that the pace is lively, the characterizations on target and the atmosphere frothy. He is helped by a cast that brings a great deal more commitment to the project than it deserves. Tony Martin is likeable and engaging in the lead role, although he's not quite actor enough to pull off this particular charade. Rita Hayworth is pure gold in this relatively early starring role. Although she's given very little to do musically, she uses her rare charisma and innate desirability to delightful effect. Eric Blore and Alan Mowbray make a fine comic team, and the rest of the supporting cast is dependable and diverting. ~ Craig Butler, All Movie Guide