| Andrew Bednarski |
Little Phineas |
| Kirsten Bishop |
Nancy |
| Sean Hewitt |
Coley Draper |
| Michael Higgins |
Phineas Taylor |
| Harry Hill |
Mr. Fish |
| Patty Maloney |
Older Tom Thumb |
| Laura Press |
Charity |
| John Roney |
Young Barnum |
| Rob Roy |
Horace Greeley |
| Hanna Schygulla |
Jenny Lind |
| Michael Sinelnikoff |
Lord in Waiting |
| Philip Spensley |
Deacon Cox |
| Chris Wiggins |
Olmstead |
| Thick Wilson |
Museum Passerby |
| Burt Lancaster |
Phineas T. Barnum |
| Bronwen Mantel |
Queen Victoria |
| Deborah Hancock |
Caroline |
| Joan Heney |
Mrs. Stratton |
| Joe Cazalet |
James Gordon Bennett |
| Rummy Bishop |
Bank Doorman |
| Richard Dumont |
Hummel |
| Lorena Gale |
Joyce Heth |
| Shawn Lawrence |
R.W. Lindsay |
| Sandor Raski |
Young Tom Thumb |
| John McCorkell |
Heckler Roberts |
| Tony Rabinow |
Matthew Scott |
| Sam Lemarquand |
Chauncey Jerome |
| John Stanzil |
Tap Dancer |
| The Royal Hanneford Circus |
|