First off, I would like to say that in the "The Director would like to thank" credits of this film Terrence Mallick is thanked, proceeding directly to Jerry Bruckheimer....I never thought I'd see those two names together. :-)
But to more important things...This film astounded me. It is in the realm of Mystic River. It is a crime drama that actually questions what the true meaning of the crime is, and how human nature reacts. Except with this film it is just as enough of the audience reacting as it is the characters reacting to their surroundings. The story plays out beautifully. The acting is wonderful. And the director, no matter how self-conscious, never is self indulgent and serves the story so well, that not only every scene has purpose, but even every single shot helps foward the story. It is so well thought out, however, that it moves away from brilliance to more of a great example of the act of filmmaking. Casey Affleck deserves an Oscar for this, and older brother Ben at least deserves a nod. I think he finally found he belongs behind the camera instead of in front of it, and I would have to agree.
All this being said, this film is one of the best of the year. It's real, it's gritty, it's provacative, and it hands you such a powerful story that you are forced to look inside yourself and figure out why you wanted the things that normally happen in these types of films to happen here, and why it's so important to question that.