I have asked certain users on Spout to recommend a movie to me. I will be blogging about these films as I watch them. This film was recommended to me by protexblue
House of Bamboo
It wasn't too long ago that I met protexblue on Spout, but I liked him right away after browsing his movie ratings. And then after a couple correspondences and seeing a few of his posts, I knew this guy was someone I wanted to listen to. His taste in movies is fantastic. His observations and insights are acute, and his ability to put them into words is adroit. Here is how he put his recommendation of this movie to me:
I'm recommending Sam Fuller's House of Bamboo based on the mixture of Japanese and classic American films in your 5 star films list. For whatever reason the DVD was released in the "Fox Film Noir" collection, even though it's from the mid 50s pulp thriller shot in color cinemascope - so you see a lot of people giving it mid-range reviews online because they were expecting heavy shadows and dutch angles. I first tracked it down after reading it was Godard's favorite Fuller film, and if you see Contempt or Two or Three Things I Know About Her you can really see the influence on his widescreen compositions. I'll leave the description to the back of the box or Netflix - but all you really need to know is Sam Fuller directs Robert Ryan vs Robert Stack in Tokyo.
I thought his recognizing of my penchant for Samuel Fuller and Japanese cinema was astute, and thus the recommendation made sense to me. I was looking forward to seeing more Fuller films, although this one was not originally near the top of my list.
Although he mentions Godard in his recommendation, I have only seen one Godard film, and did not like it. So I can't comment on that connection. But I will say that the compositions were probably the most striking and enjoyable part of the film. I'm remembering an interesting directly above crane shot. And also a lot of interesting things with windows, and those paper Japanese walls, and other translucent surfaces.
The story took me a while to get into. I like Robert Stack, but most of my exposure to him has actually been more of his self parody comedy style of recent years. But now watching him in this movie I kind of feel like he was always a parody of sorts. His character is largely a shallow portrayal of the stereotypical film noir protagonist, but bordering on being a cipher. Robert Ryan's character however is much more interesting, even if a bit bemusing at times. *SPOILER* His blatant carelessness at the end of the movie during his plot to finish off Robert Stack seems so out of character with his calm and precise manner of the rest of the film, that it lowered my enjoyment of the film. Of course the homosexual subtext (which according to the audio commentary Ryan and Fuller had worked out but Stack was completely oblivious to [as was his character] during the filming) may provide the reason to why Ryan may have been so flustered at finding out Stack was an undercover investigator. But still, his plan goes from working so well, to turning into such a disaster by his own carelessness so quickly that it still seems out of character.
The fact that the film takes place in Japan provides some more interesting scenery and a bit of culture clash to the context, but mostly the Japanese stay on the perifery of the story without becoming too central. The love story with Mariko becomes part of the plot, but again the real meat of the story at least for me came from the interactions with Ryan's character Sandy Dawson. Fuller makes a few observations about Japanese culture and they way they see love and romance and racism, but it didn't hold as much depth as I was hoping for.
See the movie for the compositions and for Robert Ryan. This was worth watching, and I will watch more Fuller films, but unfortunately this was my least favorite of his so far.
Next I'm hoping I can see Johnny Guitar, protexblue's number one recommendation for me if it ever comes out on Region 1 DVD or to a theater near me!
Samuel Fuller:
Total feature length films seen: 5
Previous average film score: 9.25
New average film score: 8.8
Rating: 7/10