Telluride 2008 Festival
Advertisement
Sign in
Username   Password         Forgot password?
Wanna join? Tour Spout | Sign up

radiogerbil Blog

  • Poorly Made and Pointless

    1 out of 1 people found this review helpful. [What do you think?]
    Under discussion:

    Baise-Moi  (2000)

    Undeterred by the countless warnings I received on this movie, I watched it, expecting an impactful story of two objectified women taking out their rage through the only means available to them. 

    It's anything but impacting.  From both a plot and a technical viewpoint, it's awful.  The film is very poorly made with very low quality film, awful framing, and extreme close-ups that usually lose the subject.

    The plot is thin at best and fails to make any kind of statement.  If the women had been normal before their various traumatic experiences, then I might be able to buy into their murder-and-sex spree, but both were women of ill-repute with little reason to snap.   

    Though it was created to disturb, it really just bored me.  The characters are impossible to relate to or feel empathy for, the plot is hashed together, and the graphic content is almost laughable in its pointlessness.  Perhaps I'm just very jaded, but this film utterly fails to communicate any kind of social commentary.


  • Stale, Tasteless

    Was this review helpful? [Be the first to tell us!]
    Under discussion:

    Ratatouille  (2007)

    I just saw "Ratatouille" tonight, and I'm baffled as to why it's receiving such rave reviews.  It's not bad, but it's not that good either.  It just...is.  It's as forgettable as "Ghost Rider."  Hardly anything stands out.  The story is stale, there's very little humor (unless you enjoy endless slapstick), and the characters are shrug-inducing.  The animation is very good though.  It's impressive to see how far Pixar has come technically.  I just wish that the story was better executed.  There's only so much humor you can get out of a kid being controlled by a rat.

    Ironically, most of the humor came from identifying which Disney movie stories were almost outright copied in the script.  There is, of course, the very obvious nod to "The Little Mermaid" when the father rat warns his naive son to "stay away from humans, they're dangerous" among other similarities.  And there's the "American Tail" reference with him being separated from his family, drifting through the sewers, and finally running into them in the big city.  And then there's the very odd similarity between the head chef and Gollum.  Many of his facial expressions nearly had me yelping out, "Gollum!  Gollum!" or "My Precioussssssss!" as he leaps for the papers the rat steals. 

    A friend called this film delicious.  To me it tasted like stale graham crackers.  It's fine in a pinch, but it's not all that great.

    Overall, it's not bad or great.  It's just ok.

    (By the way, I felt the same about "Monsters, Inc." and "Finding Nemo."  So now you know if you can heed my review.  If you loved those movies, you'll enjoy this.  If not, then heed me...heeeeeed meeeee!)


  • Smart Sci-Fi

    Was this review helpful? [Be the first to tell us!]
    Under discussion:

    Cypher  (2002)

    I've been waiting for this movie for a while ever since it showed in the Dublin independent movie hall.  Finally, after years, it's been released to America, and I don't know why it took so long.  Perhaps it was trying to put some distance between it and "The Matrix" because the two share some minute similarities.

    This low-budget movie demands much concentration from the viewer and demands that they figure some details out for themselves, but it's ultimately quite rewarding in the end with a twist that neither I nor my friend expected.

    The story centers around a very awkward accountant who volunteers to spy on rival companies for a technology company called DigiCorp.  What he doesn't realize is that far more is going on than merely spying on trade shows.  Soon he is embroiled in a world that he cannot understand nor escape from.  Relying on shadowy figures and his panicky nuerosis, he gropes blindly from one revelation to another.

    Lucy Liu's acting could have been better, but what can you expect from one of the new Charlie's Angels?  While the story isn't as fast-paced or exciting as it could have been, it is nonetheless a smart sci-fi thriller that will keep you guessing.

  • Love Amidst Filth

    Was this review helpful? [Be the first to tell us!]
    Under discussion:

    Closer  (2004)

    I always feel better about myself after watching a movie like “Closer” because the characters are so messed up that they make me look angelic.  Rife with graphic sexual dialogue and nudity, the film isn’t for everyone, but it’s a well-done and raw film that strips mankind down to its basest instincts and lays its feelings bare for all to see.  I liked it for its honesty and powerful dialogue.  I would even watch it again, but, like “Sin City,” it left me feeling a little dirty after the credits rolled.

    Clive Owen is as masterful as ever, and Natalie Portman does very well also.  Jude Law is so good at being detestable, and he’s very detestable in this film.  Julia Roberts said in an interview that she hated her character in this movie because she’s so disgusting, and she is.  Damien Rice has two songs in the movie (“The Blower’s Daughter” & “Cold Water”) which adds a lot of depth and meaning to the movie because the characters, for all their selfishness, still cannot take their eyes off of each other.  This has disastrous results for some but delivers hope to others.  Ultimately, it’s about forgiveness and being able to see past the filth to see the person you love and stick with them through their follies.


  • Disappointing and Overblown

    Was this review helpful? [Be the first to tell us!]
    Under discussion:

    In summation, Pirates 3squpkI3k can best be explained by the following equation:

    Story = Bad
    Convoluted, Pointless Plot = Good
    Special Effects = Popular, profitable movie
    Convoluted, Pointless Plot + Special Effects x 100 = Pirates 3squpkI3k

    It basically wasn't worth the money spent to see it.  Sure, it was relatively nice to look at, but it was a case study of style over substance.  If you look beyond the countless explosions and soaring body count, you'll realize that there isn't much of a story there.  Did they have to spend 3 hours to bring Captain Jack Sparrow from the dead so he can kill Davy Jones?  Hardly.  They just like to screw us, though.  I think the studios are having a secret competition between themselves of who can sucker-punch the audience the most.  Right now, Spidey 3 is in first place with Pirates 3squpkI3k rapidly catching up.

    This 3rd (and unfortunately probably not the last) installment in the Pirates franchise is the darkest and least funny of the bunch.  It has more plot holes than plot points, more plot twists than a salsa dancer on speed, and more impossible feats of heroics than...you get the idea.  Their mantra seems to have been, "When in doubt, blow something up" or "When the plot falls apart, distract the sheep with lots of fighting and stunts."  Death becomes entertainment, and what better way to excite and entertain the audience than with lots and lots and lots of deaths? 

    Pirates 3squpkI3k is like cotton candy with roman candles shooting out of it.  There's a lot going on and pretty to look at, but there's nothing actually there.  It's brainless and pointless with enough recycled material to make you think you were watching a mash-up of the previous two films.

    One of the most intellectually insulting elements is the character of Elizabeth Swan.  Her acting was horrendous.  She's a pretty face, nothing more.  She was so unconvincing that my Dad asked me, "Is she the child of some famous Hollywood couple?  Because I can't think of any other reason why she got that job."  Well put.  Movies usually require some willing suspension of disbelief but asking the audience to believe that she could be a pirate lord who can rip off the Braveheart speech nearly word for word to inspire the fierce pirate hordes is asking just a bit too much.  *shudder*  I still shudder whenever I recall that pirated version of William Wallace's "Sons of Scotland" speech.  What a lazily written movie.

    The entire film is such a disappointment.  It just goes to show that even a $300 million dollar budget can't buy a quality story.  Save your money and go rent Gladiator or The Lord of the Rings trilogy.  This summer's films are turning out to be stinkers.


  • Fun Neo-Noir

    Was this review helpful? [Be the first to tell us!]
    Under discussion:

    Neo-Noir is an odd beast.  It encompasses everything from “L.A. Confidential” to “The Usual Suspects” to “Pulp Fiction.”  One of the latest additions to this genre is the satirical “Kiss Kiss, Bang Bang.”

    Whereas most neo-noir films take themselves and their content seriously, KKBB makes fun of the genre while also remaining true to its finer points.  Like other neo-noir films, nothing is as it seems and plot twists fly around as fast and plentiful as bullets.  This film's difference is that the lead character knows he’s in a movie and pokes fun at the narrator device as well as miraculous survivals and how-did-I-not-think-of-that plot twists.

    The story begins with our lead man running away from cops after trying to boost some toys.  In his haste, he accidentally runs into a movie audition and manages to land the part.  He’s then flown out to Hollywood where a private detective starts giving him lessons on how to be a convincing detective on screen.  On his first night of training, they accidentally witness a murder that embroils both of them in a convoluted murder mystery/thriller. 

    Throughout it all, our unassuming lead man hooks up with his high school crush (who is, of course, somehow embroiled in it as well) and wittily slices up L.A. life in a sharp script that would make Joss Whedon proud. 

    The film’s greatest assets are its sharp, sarcastic dialogue and bizarre plot twists.  Despite its rambling, obtuse ending, the film is very enjoyable and highly recommended.


  • Ultimately Empty

    Was this review helpful? [Be the first to tell us!]
    Under discussion:

    Stander  (2003)

    Criminals hold an odd sway over the imagination of the general public.  While most are nothing but petty deviants, the elite (the mob, bank robbers, serial killers) are treated as if they are celebrities.  A strange fascination surrounds these people for they have dared to do what most can’t even imagine.  They aren’t larger than life, but they achieve a mythology that separates them from the rest of humanity.  They are in a class of their own and so books, shows and movies are made of these fascinating (and often deplorable) characters.

    One such criminal who’s reputation far exceeded the man was Captain Stander, a police detective in Johannesburg, South Africa, who became a notorious bank robber even while he still served as a cop.

    Inspired by righteous outrage, fueled with gleeful ambition and ending in a tragic waste, Stander was a good man who used the wrong tool to fight injustice.

    The film opens with him as the naive police officer, doing his duty, serving the public, etc, but then he witnesses the brutal massacre of peaceful demonstrators protesting the cruel reign of Apartheid.   Disgusted by this display he rebels against the system by becoming the most notorious and popular bank robber ever in South Africa.

    While the film is suspenseful and fun, it’s strangely empty.  It rushes through the back-story and the heists in a rush to squeeze everything in.  Through his record-setting bank robberies (47 in about a year) he left behind no discernable message.  He made no demands, no claims, nothing that would separate him from the legions of petty thieves.

    Perhaps the most damaging feature of a film like Stander is that it makes light of crime.  It makes it look fun and harmless.  After all, they’re not killing anyone, they’re just stealing money, and a person can always earn more money.

    While I enjoy films like Snatch and Lock Stock and Two Smoking Barrels, their fun and light-hearted take on the underworld is nothing to emulate.  The underworld is called thus because it is ruled by darkness. 

    Compared with other biopics, Stander is fun but ultimately empty.


  • I prefer the Disney version

    Was this review helpful? [Be the first to tell us!]
    Under discussion:

    In keeping with my Criterion binge, I watched the original, full-length version of "Beauty and the Beast," and it’s very different from the Disney reincarnation.

    In this 1946 French film, Belle is the youngest of four children of a recently impoverished merchant. Her two older sisters spend all their day pretending they are still rich and try to get into fancy parties while they make Belle slave away at home doing the chores. It was very similar to Cinderella in that regard except there were no benign mice singing her name. Besides the previous notes, the major differences between the original and the Disney version are as follows:

    - She has an older brother whose best friend tries to woo Belle.

    - Her brother’s gambling debts impoverish the family.

    - Her father isn’t an inventor.

    - Her father gets lost in the forest on his way back from the port, and the beast only attacks him when he tries to take a rose back for Belle.

    - The Beast lets the father return home only if one of his children is willing to be punished in his stead.

    - The Beast isn’t ferocious at all to Belle and instead humbles himself before her whenever possible. He’s more of a lapdog than a beast.

    - There aren’t any talking dishes, no dancing cutlery, no magical dressers, and no musical numbers.

    - The roses are just one of four elements in the Beast’s magical kingdom.

    - Spirits turned him into a beast in order to take revenge on his parents who didn’t believe in magic.

    - When Belle breaks the spell by looking kindly on the Beast, he turns into a more handsome version of her brother’s best friend.

    - Instead of the dark castle turning into a kingdom of light, the Beast / now prince takes Belle in his arms and together they fly away to a magical kingdom.

    The gerbil’s verdict: 3 dancing teapots out of 5. I prefer the Disney version.


  • Haunting and Powerful

    Was this review helpful? [Be the first to tell us!]
    Under discussion:

    “The Sweet Hereafter” is an exquisitely crafted film in which pain and loss reign supreme when a small town loses most of their children to a devastating bus accident.  Shortly thereafter, a driven attorney arrives and tries to reopen their pain and stir their grief into a class-action lawsuit against the bus manufacturer. 

    The lone survivor of the accident, a teenage girl, narrates the film by using the fable of the Pied Piper as the framework for the film’s events.  The story is told in three simultaneous narrative streams that deftly weave together to form a beautiful narrative.  The backstory of how the accident happened forms the first stream while the aftershock and lawsuit forms the second.  The third stream is quite enigmatic and is never resolved but provides much depth to the life of the attorney and shows why he does what he does.

    Ian Holm is fantastic as the seemingly amoral attorney who drives the parents into a frenzy of revenge, but his character is haunted by the unstoppable self-destruction of his junkie daughter.  Frequently through the film she calls him on his cell-phone, asking for money to support her habit.  Beaten down by years of this, Holm’s love for his daughter has eroded into duty.  He cares for her because she is his, nothing more.  Desperate for some solace for his grief, he rallies other grief-stricken parents to sue ambiguous powers in a vain attempt to lessen his own pain.  The film is more about him than about the townspeople, but their pain is vivid and powerful as well. 

    Rife with powerful performances, a beautiful soundtrack, gorgeous cinematography, and an original, fresh story, this film is a must-see.


  • Idealist's Transformation

    Was this review helpful? [Be the first to tell us!]
    Under discussion:

    Straw Dogs  (1971)

    It's easy to say you're a pacifist, but how does one live it when they are truly put to the test?  In this film, Dustin Hoffman's character is a mild-mannered mathematician who moves to a small English town with his wife to escape from the rampant violence in America.  Ironically, violence and degradation are all that meets him in his new home.


    Immediately after he moves in, he and his wife are constantly harassed and abused by his neighbors which culminates in a brutal violation of his wife by a couple local men.  No wonder it was banned in Great Britain.

    Though he never discovers the violation, his idealism is put to the ultimate test when a group of drunken locals try to storm his house to kill a man he is caring for.  The ensuing violence is so strong that it is still disturbing though the film is over thirty years old.  The last half hour of the movie is what "Home Alone" would have been like had Alfred Hitchcock directed it.  Tense, graphically violent and poignant, Hoffman has to choose between living in his theoretical ideology or living in the real world.  A must for anyone interested in psychology, sociology or any other -ology.  Man, this is a powerful movie.


  • Darkly humorous

    Was this review helpful? [Be the first to tell us!]
    Under discussion:

    Infidelity has never been so funny. Convinced that his wife cheated on him while he was abroad, a conductor (Harrison) imagines a series of revenges while he conducts his orchestra through a series of soaring passions and gloomy depressions.


    Like anyone, his passions see-saw between homicidal revenge and selfless sacrifice. He sees himself doing the absolute worst to his love, and in a moment of benign generosity he sees himself letting her go with forgiveness and grace, all the while remaining the wronged one. Interestingly, when the concert finally concludes, he rushes home to carry out his series of revenges, but every one of them falters and goes completely against how he imagined. A darkly humorous movie, this Criterion is a gem.


  • What "Crash" should have been

    1 out of 1 people found this review helpful. [What do you think?]
    Under discussion:

    Spike Lee’s explosive race drama, "Do the Right Thing," is what "Crash" should have been. Whereas "Crash" had too many vignettes to fully develop into impacting stories, "Do the Right Thing" tightens the focus to the racial tensions between African Americans, Italians, Koreans and Mexicans all living together in one city block in NYC. Set all during one day in the middle of a vicious heat wave, the film uses the heat to set the characters on edge and disorient the audience. 

    The center of this volatile drama is "Sal’s Pizzaria" - the neighborhood pizza shop. Run by Sal and his sons for 30 years, the place is a fixture. He knows everyone, and everyone knows him. All is well until one radical black man becomes furious that Sal only has pictures of Italian-Americans on the wall. Sal kicks him out for disruption, and so the guy sulks around the neighborhood, trying to rally a boycott of the pizzaria. He only succeeds in recruiting one guy, but it proves to be enough. The simmering tension finally explodes when both the black radicals and Sal react irrationally and get into a fight which snowballs into a huge disaster for all parties.

    Strangely, most of the film is quite humorous. Though there is a growing palpable tension simmering just below the surface, the humor seems to promise a peaceful conclusion to this race drama, but this is Spike Lee. One character constantly blares the rap song, "Fight the Power," over his boombox wherever he goes which would suggest that Lee is encouraging violence. It would seem that way except for his raw portrayal of the blacks’ own foolishness and mob mentality. While the tension simmers, a black radio jockey constantly appeals for peace and understanding. It’s as if Lee doesn’t know whether or not violence or peace is the best path to helping his people. Early in the film, a retarded man holds up a picture of Malcolm X and Martin Luther King, Jr. together and consistently badgers the neighbors to buy the pictures. At the end of the film, Lee quotes King’s stance against race violence and X’s stance for race violence. I think the film tries to depict the consequences of both peaceful and violent race resolutions.

    This film is much stronger than "Crash" because it intensely focuses on a few, tightly-interwoven conflicts in a claustrophobic setting. "Crash" instead gave a broad overview on race relations in L.A., and while that was insightful, with the exception of one vignette, it didn’t impact me.

    My only complaints with Lee's film are its weak ending and that several scenes lose their dramatic tension due to the film’s annoying upbeat jazz soundtrack.


  • Unfortunately Dull

    Was this review helpful? [Be the first to tell us!]
    Under discussion:

    Dead Man  (1995)

    Johnny Depp is one of our finest actors, but even he has some duds.  Case in point, "Dead Man."  The premise sounds promising when it tells us that Depp plays a mild-mannered accountant who gets accused of murders he didn't commit and has to go on the run to evade the bounty hunters.  It sounds like a thrilling adventure, but it's not.  The pace is very lethargic, and Depp spends most of the film looking bewildered.  The strong points of the film are the random bizarre characters and killer soundtrack.  I should have known it would be weird  when the credits named Indie filmmaker icon Jim Jarmusch as its writer and director.  If you're looking for a rousing movie, keep searching the aisles, but if you're in the mood for a very offbeat and weird film, check it out.  If nothing else, its awesome soundtrack and black-and-white cinematography will leave you feeling smarter than all those mainstream viewers.

  • Unfortunately Dull

    Was this review helpful? [Be the first to tell us!]
    Under discussion:

    Dead Man  (1995)

    Johnny Depp is one of our finest actors, but even he has some duds.  Case in point, "Dead Man."  The premise sounds promising when it tells us that Depp plays a mild-mannered accountant who gets accused of murders he didn't commit and has to go on the run to evade the bounty hunters.  It sounds like a thrilling adventure, but it's not.  The pace is very lethargic, and Depp spends most of the film looking bewildered.  The strong points of the film are the random bizarre characters and killer soundtrack.  I should have known it would be weird  when the credits named Indie filmmaker icon Jim Jarmusch as its writer and director.  If you're looking for a rousing movie, keep searching the aisles, but if you're in the mood for a very offbeat and weird film, check it out.  If nothing else, its awesome soundtrack and black-and-white cinematography will leave you feeling smarter than all those mainstream viewers.

  • Timeless

    Was this review helpful? [Be the first to tell us!]
    Under discussion:

    The Fountain  (2006)

    "The Fountain" is easily one of the most creative and original films I have ever seen, and from opening to closing, this epic, yet intimate, film took me on a gorgeous mindblower that challenges, moves, and delights. 

    Three stories are happening at the same time, with the same characters, and they all interweave to form an intricate pattern or mosaic of emotion and beauty.

    It’s a powerful view of human mortality that’s both emotive and cerebral, and it also creates a tangible mood much like “Blade Runner” or “Fear & Loathing” does. 

    This film is more than a movie; it’s a work of art.   The rich cinematography, stellar acting, and haunting soundtrack create a living, breathing piece of art that continues to move and shift every time I see it.  It does what so few films can...it moves, challenges and delights.  And it stays with you long after the credits roll.


 

Like what you're reading?

Subscribe
Search
  Go

Browse previous
<September 2008>
SunMonTueWedThuFriSat
31123456
78910111213
14151617181920
21222324252627
2829301234
567891011

Dig through the archives

Categories
 


Advertisement