Frem Here To Awesome Festival
Advertisement

paul on spout.com

I've seen it.

Under discussion:
So I finally checked out Cane Toads: An Unnatural History. It's alright. Worth watching. Not as hysterical as I expected, however the Cane Toad is a fascinating creature and this documentary is a substantial course in Cane Toad.

Gist: Cane Toads are originally from Hawaii. In the 1930's, sugar cane farmers in Australia were losing entire crops to beetles. Some "expert" at a conference in Puerto Rico asserted that Cane Toads were the best measure of prevention against said beetle. So one guy halled a boat-load over to Aussie and started spawing them in his pond.  Long story short, the Cane Toad had no natural predators in Australia, adapted beautifully to the climate, and reproduced with an alarming survival ratio. So alarming it's uncanny and the documentary speculates that this may be one of the most robust creatures on the continent.

I found the most fascinating part of this doc to be how humans react emotionally to the toads. The creature is either loved or adored. Some residents of the northern coast–where the toads live–take civic pride in having them around and consider Cane Toads to be a tourist attraction. Then there are the loathers who often speak of destroying every Cane Toad they have the opportunity to come across. One long shot is composed of a van–driven by a scientist–swerving back and forth down a stretch of country road picking off Cane Toads under his driver side tire.

All in all, this documentary is chuckling at a hideous creature and the rural residents who love it. So it has the patronizing flavor of big city filmmakers poking fun at a small town subject. I think in the past twenty years since Cane Toads was made, audiences have become more sophisticated in recognizing objective story telling. For the most part, we expect less judgement and more responsibility from a documentary filmmaker and, in that way, this documentary is a dated disappointment.

posted on Wednesday, April 05, 2006 8:53 AM by paul


Was this review helpful?
Yeah Yeah Nope Nope



Comment    Email me new comments.


PammyK
Posted Friday, April 21, 2006 10:34 AM

So I watched it last night (Thursday evening movie). I found the part about the dead female disturbing. There were many disturbing parts to the movie, but there were also very informational, touching and funny parts. I always love a good baby animal scene, and this movie has a pretty good one.

Overall I felt sad for most of the people because they were so honest and so passionate about what they were saying, and I believe they were being totally honest. At the same time, it was funny enough and interesting enough to overlook that raw and honest glimpse into humanity - or maybe not overlook it, but to realize that it isn't that sad, its just sorta how people are.
patches
Posted Monday, April 10, 2006 11:38 AM

Alright, to when it was made, 1987, it was great. So sue me if I enjoyed it Paul. Don't you have films that you adore while others just smile and nod? I guess this is one of those Tuesday early evening watches. But, you do have to admit that the bit about the male toad mounting female roadkill is good for a chuckle...
PammyK
Posted Thursday, April 06, 2006 10:41 AM

I like watching documentaries like this, but is it a Friday night movie or a Tuesday early evening movie?


Advertisement