I've seen lots of different versions of "A Christmas Carol" and this one isn't the best, but it was on TV last night so I watched it. I liked it of course. You just can't help feeling so so sad about Tiny Tim and you can just feel the fresh cold air and the excitement of Christmas morning when Scrooge wakes up and realizes that he hasn't missed Christmas and there is still time to change and buy that huge goose for the Crachits. Its such a wonderful story that I'm not sure it matters which one you're watching. My main complaint about this one is that Scrooge was bald and younger looking - he should have wispy white hair and be ugly.