MANHATTAN MELODRAMA
1934 – NR – 90 Min.
D: W.S. Van Dyke
S: Clark Gable – William Powell – Myrna Loy
Warner Home Entertainment DVD – Released as part of the Myrna Loy And William Powell Collection
Fullscreen / Dolby Digital Mono
Extras: Comedy Short – Classic Cartoon – Theatrical Trailer
Though most notorious for being the film John Dillinger was gunned down after seeing, Manhattan Melodrama has more to offer than its notable connection with historical trivia. The now overly familiar plotline tells the story of two boyhood friends who helped each other navigate through some amazing hardships only to end up on opposite sides of the law in adulthood. Familiar though it may be, these particular plot conventions have rarely been used in quite this way. Blackie (Gable) has nothing but respect and admiration for his old buddy Jim (Powell) and wants only the greatest success for him. They remain fast friends, but that friendship becomes more complicated (and strained) as Jim’s political career begins to take off. Also, there is Eleanor (Loy). She begins with Blackie but soon finds herself in love with Jim and the happy, secure, life he can offer. Not even this turn of events can sour the friendship between the protagonists. When murder enters into the scenario Jim will find himself, and his relationship, nearly crushed beneath the weight of his moral quandaries. Excellent performances and tight direction save this from becoming silly and overwrought. The first section of the film, featuring Mickey Rooney as the young Blackie, seems to be heading down that very path, but as soon as the characters reach adulthood we are treated to a relentlessly engaging tale that is as powerful as it is satisfying. Loy is fantastic, as always, and this marked her first pairing with Powell. Also of interest; a musical number performed at a club, The Bad In Every Man, was the original incarnation of the song Blue Moon before it was rewritten to be more commercial friendly. Whether you are a classic movie fan or just love seeing Powell and Loy together on screen, Manhattan Melodrama comes highly recommended.