I was talking to friend about it the other night. "Yeah i've seen his movie Nowhere, and that's exactly where that film goes." This sort of sentiment seems par for the course for Gregg Araki. His previous movies, epitmoized by Nowhere and The Doom Generation, are sort of hellish teenage character studies. Movies with unbelievable characters engaged in mundane daily life, in a sureallist punk landscape. Typecast as part of 'the New Queer Cinema' of the early nineties, Araki is often chastised for making films that lack depth. I've always understood this view, but I defend his work as fevered wish fulfillments. Movies whose point isn't in the message, but in the telling. So now he comes out of left field with a real film. An accomplished work that, while containing definite Araki style, is unlike anything he's made before. This is a heartbreaking work of staggering genius, to quote Dave Eggars.
Mysterious Skin tells the story of two Kansas youths who are molested by thier little league coach at the age of 9. This becomes the dominant event in both their lives but with very different consequences. Neil embraces the escapades with 'Coach' as a type of paternal love. He feels special, and unique from all the attention. The wierd sex games he's asked to participate in carry with them the promise of a caring adult. Coach stands in contrast to Neil's mother, who for all her good intentions and genuine love for her son, is nonetheless an absentee mother. Prefering to spend time with various boyfriends, than pay attantion to her child. Brian's homelife on the other hand seems at first to be a bit more normal. He has a loving mother, patient older sister and enjoys a modest middle class life. Brian too though, is bereft a suitable father figure. His own, more inclined to a kind of apathetic parenting.
The film opens with a scene of young Neil in a state of pure joy. Cereal raining over him, he laughs and smiles to the sound of angelic music. This is not what one might expect from a moive about child abuse. Coach's seduction techniques are much closer to reality than you usually see in a film of the same subject. He's likable, cool, and attractive. This is a guy we'd want to hang out with. Instead of showing him a pure monster, Araki shows how the monster fools everyone.
Neil's experience dominates the first third of the movie. Brian's experience is told mainly through the aftermath of the event, and later, in flash back. For Brian, this was not an initiation into the world of emotionless sex. It was a severely traumatic event. So affecting, that young Brian blocks the experience out, causing him to suffer from psychosomatic symptoms.
As it moves into its main section, concerned with the boys around the age of 19 it becomes clear how crippled Brian and Neil actually are. Now a male prostitute, Neil tries to contextualize his experience by submersing himself in a world of emotionless sex for hire. Brian on the other hand is a complete introvert, 'wierdly asexual' as one character describes him. All of his lost time, and eerie circumstances, coupled with dreams of a vague presence hovering over him, have convinced him that he was abducted by aliens. His frantic search for truth eventually leads him to Neil, and the truth and absolution they've been respectively searching for.
The movie is not about coach. It's about Neil and Brian, it's about the effect the abuse they endured has had on them. Coach is a catalyst, something to set the stage, nothing more. Yet he is shown as a complex character. It would be easy to write him off as evil, and he most assuredly is, but this isn't his story.
By far, Mysterious Skin, is Gregg Araki's best film to date. There are times when the flair of Doom Generation is present, as in some of Neil's encounters, or the movies Brian watches For the most part,though, this feels like the beginning of a new phase of filmmaking for the director. Who knew he was actually this talented. It's dreamy and brutal all at the same time. When the credits finally roll, you can't helped but be gripped with a realization of the sheer, unbridled horror of it all.
The screening I attended with filled with gasps and shrieks, as the mostly middle aged gay male crowd suddenly realized they weren't watching a 'New Queer Cinema' movie, but one from a pure artist. They had gotten in way over their heads by underestimating Araki, and he made them pay dearly for it.